Sunday, August 25, 2013

Vancouver, home of Speculators

I found this on Vancouver Condo info, hat tip China bust, it is a legal action brought by investors who purchased units at the Olympic Village and who now want their contracts  rescinded .

They are suing the City of Vancouver.

Here is the list of investors named in the law suit:

ok J. Choi, Il Ho Ahn and Ra Young Choi,
Yen Hai Doan, Tian Gao, Thomas Gisby,
Jung Gu Han and Hyun Joo Han,
Jung Kyoo Han and Sung Sub Han,
In Cheol Jang and Sunkyu Choi,
Heebo Kang and Soon Bin Kang,
Mi Hyang Jin and Yung Jun Kwon,
Mohamad Lafta, Hak Hyung Lee, Flora Kwangah Lee,
Sang Wook Kwang and Hyun Jung Lee,
Kyoung Won Lee and Nam Won Park,
Gordon Mah, Wendy Milligan,
Sook Ja Oh and Mu Hong Oh,
Young Ock Park and Yi Yong Pan,
Young Mi Seo, Shermar Holdings Ltd.,
Susana Yim and Hardy Yim,
Sook Ja Yoon and Eul Byong Yoon

Here is the case, and from what I can understand, the first question is whether the City of Vancouver can be deemed to be the developer of the project. I definitely do not know or even understand the legal intricacies. 

But I am an over-taxed Vancouver resident worrying about cuts to other City-funded services or a Provincial bail-out. I am also a student of the speculative frenzy in this city, where Billions of Dollars of real estate are bought and flipped or bought and left empty.

A few things come to mind:

1) The names are apparently mostly Korean. I don't know whether they are resident in Canada or not. They could be German or Mongolian, but the fact that one ethnic group has so many unhappy buyers, makes one wonder if the project was aggressively marketed to this group by a realtor.

2) Are they end users who have some concern about construction or are they speculators who are upset about the drop in value. ie were they speculating. The GetLegal blog linked thinks they are investors who bought at the top and are now regretting their decision and trying to get out of their obligations.

Certainly there have been a lot of condo projects built in this city which have been late or have had issues. When the market is flying no one seems too bothered, but once it falters the law suits start flying, like Sangrila and now OV.

3) How much more is this going to cost us? What we do know is that when lawyers have the Government as a client, ie the taxpayer, the fees are exorbitant. Let us not forget the defence that we paid for in the Dave Basi and Bobby Virk case which cost us $6 Million, before they pled guilty

To add insult to injury Judge Robert Bauman who IMVHO is a very misguided Judge, refused to allow the tax-payer's watchdog, the Auditor General, to audit the Legal bills to see how come they were sooo high.

Apparently the rights of two individuals who have already pled guilty trumps the ability of the Auditor General to do his job and point out waste and corruption.

What message does that give the legal profession? If you can get a clerk in Victoria to sign off on your billing, you are audit free!!!

I cannot believe what a carte blanche Bauman has given his fellow lawyers!

Once again I say PPP do not work. If the project is profitable, the Private keeps it, and if it doesn't the Public owns it. The financial sharks make sure they write the deals so that is how it works out. The other side of the table are well-meaning but naive councillors and city officials who are no match for the sharks. We are witnessing the result now.

Of course the councillors are mostly gone and the officials still get their bonuses and pensions and us suckers get to pick up the tab.


  1. You live in a Rent-Seeking environment.

    Twitter: @Travel_Uruguay

  2. What will $300 K get you in the US

  3. 330 new
    202 price change
    253 sold

    7409 detached
    8782 attached

  4. I think you gave those councillors and city officials too little credits. You generally don't get make it pass the party nomination process and get elected into high public offices by being naive. More likely they know exactly what would happen if/when things go sour and they know they wouldn't be around by then nor be held accountable for it. So why not take the election/campaign donations and future consulting/contract job? It is simply corruption and bribery, except sold on the cheap.

  5. 322 new
    216 price change
    203 sold

    7428 detached
    8784 attached

  6. 320 new
    184 price change
    199 sold

    7426 detached
    8763 attached

  7. Looks like all the SFH sold in West Van today went to HAM buyers. from $2M up much higher.

  8. 244 new
    132 price change
    176 sold

    7406 detached
    8749 attached

  9. 304 new
    176 price change
    214 sold

    7384 detached
    8751 attached

  10. Thank you for your post. This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site. It really gives me an insight on this topic. You can find more information about real estate here.

  11. 100 Real Estate Commission:Real estate blogs can be one of the most effective marketing tools for real estate agents. Especially when they're used properly. When you publish quality content to a real estate blog on a regular basis, you are increasing your web presence (mentioned above) You're also positioning yourself as an authority in your area. These are just a few of the reasons a blog makes a good marketing tool for real estate success.

  12. Thanks for sharing informative blog.If you want more information then visit here :vancouver condos for sale

  13. Nice Information, your blog is sharing unique information....
    Thanks for sharing!!!
    independent house for sale
    good builders in hydearabad
    premium flat in madhapur